What do IACS UR Z17 and ABS Type Approval mean for hatch cover testing?

They cover two different things. Classification society type approval – from a society such as ABS – applies to the equipment: it confirms an ultrasonic tester is fit for checking hatch cover tightness. IACS UR Z17 applies mainly to the firms and people carrying out the tests on board. Classification societies have accepted ultrasonic testing as an alternative to the hose test since 2001, provided type-approved equipment is used by qualified operators.

This guide explains what each approval means, the pass/fail standard behind them, and what to check before buying or hiring a hatch cover testing service.

Why do approvals matter for hatch cover testing?

Hatch cover tests are used for class and statutory surveys, for P&I club inspections and by shippers of water-sensitive cargo. In each case, the result has to be trusted – and it has to be repeatable, so that the same hatch tested twice gives the same answer.

That is why the equipment and the people using it are both held to a standard. As the North of England P&I Club put it in its 2011 loss prevention briefing on hatch cover testing, type-approved and calibrated equipment should always be used so that test results can be repeated.

Ultrasonic hatch cover tester in use on a bulk carrier

When did ultrasonic testing become an accepted alternative to the hose test?

According to the same North of England P&I briefing, classification societies agreed in 2001 that ultrasonic testing was an acceptable alternative to hose testing for checking the weathertight integrity of hatch covers in class and statutory inspections – on two conditions:

  • the equipment must be type approved by a classification society
  • the test must be carried out by qualified operators

For the practical differences between the two methods, see ultrasonic vs hose testing.

ABS – American Bureau of Shipping logo

What is classification society type approval?

Type approval means a classification society, such as the American Bureau of Shipping (ABS), has assessed a model of equipment and confirmed it is fit for detecting leakage in hatch covers. Approval criteria for ultrasonic hatch testers typically require that:

  • the transmitter gives a uniform Open Hatch Value (OHV) over the area being tested
  • the OHV can be adjusted to a stable value for maximum sensitivity
  • the receiver gives both an audible signal and a visual readout in decibels
  • the readout can hold peak values found during the survey
  • the equipment can be shown to achieve the society’s pass/fail criterion

These criteria are set out, for example, in DNV’s approval programme for service suppliers carrying out ultrasonic hatch tightness testing.

What is IACS UR Z17?

UR Z17 is a Unified Requirement from the International Association of Classification Societies (IACS). It sets the procedural requirements for service suppliers – the firms carrying out testing and measurement on board ships. Section 4.2 covers ultrasonic leak testing, including hatch cover tightness testing.

Its purpose is to make sure the people testing hatch covers for class and statutory purposes understand the theory of ultrasound, have practical testing experience and know the basics of hatch cover design, maintenance and repair.

Equipment specifications often mention UR Z17, but it is mainly a requirement for how testing is carried out. For the equipment itself, the key thing to look for is type approval from a recognised classification society.

What pass/fail standard do approved tests use?

Approved ultrasonic testing measures leaks against the Open Hatch Value – a reference reading taken with the hatch open. The widely used guideline is:

  • 0 dB – no leak: the cover is watertight
  • Up to 10% of the OHV – weathertight, but not fully watertight
  • Above 10% of the OHV – not weathertight; corrective action is needed

P&I clubs use the same benchmark. North of England, for example, has required that leaks found by ultrasonic testing do not exceed 10% of the OHV, with any defects put right before the ship sails. See how UT hatch tightness testing works for how the reading is taken.

What other credentials are worth checking?

Beyond type approval, a few other checks help separate well-supported equipment from the rest:

  • Manufacturing assessment – a classification society assessment of the factory where the equipment is made
  • ISO 9001 – a certified quality management system
  • A certificate of calibration and conformity – issued with each unit, with its serial number
  • A NATO Stock Number – shows the product has been codified for defence procurement
  • Professional memberships – for example with the International Institute of Marine Surveying (IIMS)
ISO certification logo
CARGO-SAFE production line in Class Instrumentation's UK factory

About CARGO-SAFE™

CARGO-SAFE™ is ABS Type Approved and is made in Class Instrumentation’s UK factory, which holds an ABS Manufacturing Assessment. Class Instrumentation is ISO 9001:2015 certified, and each unit comes with a certificate of calibration and conformity, serial number details, a full warranty and a certificate of origin confirming it is made in the UK.

CARGO-SAFE™ has NATO Stock Number 6635-99-958-4633, and Class Instrumentation is a corporate member of IIMS and a member of IMarEST. See all accreditations and affiliations.

Frequently asked questions

Yes. Classification societies have accepted ultrasonic testing as an alternative to the hose test for class and statutory inspections since 2001, as long as type-approved equipment and qualified operators are used. Always check the requirements of the vessel’s own classification society.

Not directly. UR Z17 sets requirements for the service suppliers carrying out tests on board. The equipment itself should be type approved by a recognised classification society.

For class and statutory surveys, tests should be carried out by an approved service supplier using type-approved equipment. Crews can also use ultrasonic testers for their own routine checks and maintenance.

It means the product has been codified in the NATO system, giving it a unique reference that makes it easier for defence organisations to identify and buy.

Approved testing relies on repeatable results. Equipment that is properly calibrated, with a certificate to prove it, gives readings that can be trusted and compared between surveys.